Please support our IT Water Cooler advertiser: Affiliate Marketing
Jun 11th, 2006, 7:50 pm
Last month it was revealed that the National Security Agency had been logging telephone calls since 9/11. This month, the right to privacy debate is set to ignite even further after a report in the New Scientist claims that the NSA is funding research into the harvesting of personal information from social networks such as MySpace.
This might not sound like such a big deal, until you step back and realize quite how much personal information gets posted on social networking services: who you know, what blogs you read, your political allegiances, sexual preferences and more. Things heat up when the social networking data is added to such things as financial transactions, physical movements (cellphone base stations make great tracking systems) and that phone tapping information. But that’s just the start of it; if the semantic web proposals for a common Resource Description Framework (RDF) data structure become a reality then the NSA could potentially monitor your entire online life. The whole point of RDF is to bring an unambiguous commonality to online data, making it a machine as well as people friendly place.
New Scientist quote a paper (Semantic Analytics on Social Networks) presented at the recent WWW2006 conference in Scotland, part funded by the Advanced Research and Development Activity, and showing how data from social networks and other databases can be used together to reveal personal detail. ARDA have since changed their name to the Disruptive Technology Office (DTO) but whatever the name, the role remains the same: to research critical problems facing the US intelligence community, using NSA funds. If this reminds you of the ill fated Total Information Awareness (TIA) initiative, another Pentagon program designed to track and analyze online data trails post 9/11, you are not alone. Me as well. Let’s hope the similarities don’t end with the automated intelligence profiling aspects. The TIA program was suspended in 2002 after a high profile campaign by privacy groups.
Of course nobody, and certainly not I, would argue that intelligence gathering isn’t a requirement in the fight against global terrorism. However, there’s a world of difference between focused, targeted and legal data profiling and this kind of one size fits all invasion of privacy. Between the dangers of phishing expeditions by ID thieves and fishing expeditions by The Powers That Be, perhaps it’s time we all started taking online privacy a whole lot more seriously.
This might not sound like such a big deal, until you step back and realize quite how much personal information gets posted on social networking services: who you know, what blogs you read, your political allegiances, sexual preferences and more. Things heat up when the social networking data is added to such things as financial transactions, physical movements (cellphone base stations make great tracking systems) and that phone tapping information. But that’s just the start of it; if the semantic web proposals for a common Resource Description Framework (RDF) data structure become a reality then the NSA could potentially monitor your entire online life. The whole point of RDF is to bring an unambiguous commonality to online data, making it a machine as well as people friendly place.
New Scientist quote a paper (Semantic Analytics on Social Networks) presented at the recent WWW2006 conference in Scotland, part funded by the Advanced Research and Development Activity, and showing how data from social networks and other databases can be used together to reveal personal detail. ARDA have since changed their name to the Disruptive Technology Office (DTO) but whatever the name, the role remains the same: to research critical problems facing the US intelligence community, using NSA funds. If this reminds you of the ill fated Total Information Awareness (TIA) initiative, another Pentagon program designed to track and analyze online data trails post 9/11, you are not alone. Me as well. Let’s hope the similarities don’t end with the automated intelligence profiling aspects. The TIA program was suspended in 2002 after a high profile campaign by privacy groups.
Of course nobody, and certainly not I, would argue that intelligence gathering isn’t a requirement in the fight against global terrorism. However, there’s a world of difference between focused, targeted and legal data profiling and this kind of one size fits all invasion of privacy. Between the dangers of phishing expeditions by ID thieves and fishing expeditions by The Powers That Be, perhaps it’s time we all started taking online privacy a whole lot more seriously.
This blog entry was written by Davey Winder, staff writer aka happygeek. It has received 1,856 views, 7 comments, and 2 linkbacks. 1 voter has rated this entry 5 out of 5 stars. It was promoted to featured status Jun 11th, 2006.
•
•
•
•
adobe advertising apple blog browser business daniweb data dell development economy email facebook firefox gaming google hacking hardware ibm intel internet iphone ipod linux mac malware microsoft mobile mozilla mp3 news open source privacy programming search security server software sony spam stocks technology ubuntu video vista web windows yahoo youtube
All Recent Tags Comments (Newest First)
happygeek | He's The Daddy | Jun 14th, 2006
jwenting | duckman | Jun 14th, 2006
•
•
•
•
Just because they're investigating the possibillities of doing something according to some pop-science mag which sells on juicy headlines (yes, I know that mag) doesn't mean they're actually doing it (in fact if they're investigating the possibillities it automatically means they're not doing it...).
That CFO most likely will not have told you anything you didn't have a right to know and as you have (AFAIK) no security clearance he'll certainly have told you nothing you are expected to keep confidential.
That CFO most likely will not have told you anything you didn't have a right to know and as you have (AFAIK) no security clearance he'll certainly have told you nothing you are expected to keep confidential.
happygeek | He's The Daddy | Jun 13th, 2006
jwenting | duckman | Jun 13th, 2006
•
•
•
•
The NSA would be foolish not to use the internet to gather data on people they're keeping an eye on.
After all, those people also use the internet themselves for intel gathering and communications purposes...
And oh, they're not listening in on all your phonecalls. It's no more or less than what the IRS gets already during tax audits on your telco, the information about when calls were made from which to what number and how long they lasted.
After all, those people also use the internet themselves for intel gathering and communications purposes...
And oh, they're not listening in on all your phonecalls. It's no more or less than what the IRS gets already during tax audits on your telco, the information about when calls were made from which to what number and how long they lasted.
happygeek | He's The Daddy | Jun 13th, 2006
'Stein | Lapsed Skeptic | Jun 13th, 2006
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Originally Posted by happygeek
perhaps it’s time we all started taking online privacy a whole lot more seriously.
Can't agree with ya more. And ya, I agree with Comatose. One of the better articles in a while (not that the other ones were bad.)
By the way, do ya kno of any other sites this guy posts at?
Thanks.
Comatose | Moderator | Jun 12th, 2006
•
•
•
•
I've read a lot of good ones since you've been writing, but I really like this one.
Post Comment
•
•
•
•
Only community members can start a blog or comment on blog entries. You must register or log in to contribute.
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
DaniWeb IT Water Cooler Marketplace
Related Blog Entries
- Dell Steps Up Its Linux Offerings (13 Hours Ago)
- IBM On a Tear: Google, Microsoft - Not So Much (1 Day Ago)
- Don't "Buy It Now"? eBay Stock Slides Today After Sluggish Growth Estimate (3 Days Ago)
- Trouble with Your Vendor? Try Twitter (1 Day Ago)
- Microsoft Don’t Know Jack About UI Design (2 Days Ago)
- Is Microsoft really in talks with AOL? (2 Days Ago)
- I hate to say it but text to speech is a waste of time (4 Days Ago)
- Microsoft Denies it Demanded Changes to Yahoo Governance (3 Days Ago)
- The Netbook Market Booms with Linux Onboard (3 Days Ago)
- Sooner than I expected (3 Days Ago)
Related Forum Threads
- Dashed Border around social network (DaniWeb Community Feedback)
- Hello From Zuit Security Research! (Community Introductions)
- NVIDIA Network Access Manager (Viruses, Spyware and other Nasties)
- Creative Web Programming / Developer for a Social Network (Web Development Job Offers)
- New social networking features (DaniWeb Community Feedback)
- online community/social network (Growing an Online Community)
Featured Entry
My security clearance is high enough for me to be able to travel with children on school outings. I have a certificate and everything... :cheesy: