View Single Post
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 3,083
Reputation: jholland1964 is a name known to all jholland1964 is a name known to all jholland1964 is a name known to all jholland1964 is a name known to all jholland1964 is a name known to all jholland1964 is a name known to all 
Solved Threads: 175
Moderator
Featured Poster
jholland1964 jholland1964 is offline Offline
Posting Sensei

Re: Search Engine Redirect and Anitvirus Websites blocked

 
0
  #8
Sep 8th, 2008
Originally Posted by Nick10 View Post
I do have windows firewall enabled. Is this not secure enough? Would you recommend an additional firewall, or will I be alright with windows firewall?

I really appreciate all your help. Thanks.
Well, I know some will argue with this but I have used the Windows Firewall exclusively for well over 4 years and NEVER had a problem.
I have followed the advice of a fellow from another board, very knowledgable, I might add, who several years ago posted this argument concerning the Windows Firewall;

Windows Firewall blocks only incoming stuff whereas third-party firewalls block both incoming and outgoing stuff. This means that were you to inadvertently allow a trojan to be installed, WF would not prevent it from calling home with whatever information it had managed to harvest from your computer (passwords, monitored keystrokes, etc, etc). So, in theory, a third-party utility will offer a greater level of security than WF. However ...

... simply adopting safe surfing practices (not downloading applications from warez sites or via file-sharing utilities, not installing no-cost applications from little-known developers, etc, etc, etc) and running a good antivirus utility should be sufficient to prevent any trojans or other unwanted items from finding their way onto your computer and so a bi-directional firewall is, IMO, of less importance than many people seem to think.

Furthermore, look back over old threads and you'll find few (if any) instances of a person being "stung" as a result of using WF - but you'll find significantly more threads relating to problems caused by the use of a third-party firewall (botched updates, etc).

There is, however, no "one size fits all" answer here. Should you use your computer for online banking/shopping and should it be shared with file-sharing children, then it might not be a bad idea to install a third-party firewall, if you trust the other users to surf sensibly, then WF is probably perfectly sufficient for your needs.

This is the advice I have followed. Now granted, you did end up with this nasty item on your computer and you are running the Windows Firewall, however, I have seen this very same infection on MULTIPLE computers running any number of different and very respected firewalls both free and paid so honestly I don't believe the use of the Windows Firewall played a part in this...it is your choice. I personally am happy with the Windows Firewall.

You say...ADDITIONAL FIREWALL...Never an ADDITIONAL firewall, the rule is ONE firewall, whether it is the Windows Firewall or something else. So if you DO install another firewall then TURN OFF the Windows Firewall.
Last edited by jholland1964; Sep 8th, 2008 at 12:26 am.
Reply With Quote