Very much better than the previous ones. I can see you've put a lot of efforts into it. It makes me really impressive.

First time when I open your site, my browser crashed. Yes like others said, it's simple and has too much of free space. You gotta work it out to make better.

I agree with mikeandike22. That makes me a little blur. :) Some pages have javascript errors. Please try to double-check again.

Overall, a nice site.

Nice and clean layout. Load quite fast.

How to comment on your site? You did not post your website's url in your post. :rolleyes:

Good. But background color is not reflecting your flash. It would be better, if you change to the dark back color. Just my thought.

Nice layout! Load a little slow for me. One question is why do you put your header again at the footer? There is a duplication of header. That's a little odd.

Nice and professional. Good combination of color. Nice template.

As this is your first website, it looks fine.

Font sizes are a little big to me and left navigation menu are not very clear because the background color and menu color are almost the same.
...

I would go for second one definitely.

For the first time, I closed it right away. Sorry couldnt help. It really hurts my eyes so are visitors. You might wanna use dark red or something soft color.

Cant give you comments since this is the default theme of phpnuke. You should consider building your own theme for your site and designing the own logo. ;)

Yeah I agree with mieandike22. Your choice of fonts are ok. but I don't really like to see the wood background color. IMO, It will make your website visitors run away.

Things that I will do If I...

Your template design looks ok.

I would do, If I were you.
1. Your site does not display well even with 1024x786 resolution. Expanding. I would change it to 800x600 because most users are still...

Looks fine on FireFox. Your logo rocks!!! Your template has clean and professional look! I like it. BTW just curious, do you design the logo yourself?

Put the nice header that fits your site. Too much space is not a good idea. Like beats said, if you could show latest uploaded pictures by your users, it would be better.