KDE and Gnome = Bloatware

I'm using Redhat 9.0 in Vmware on an XP host, and have dedicated 92 Megs of RAM for the linux to run on. THis works just fine in text mode, but when I load the gui desktop it runs out of memory and starts paging like mad. Now I understand why the installer recommended 192 Megs RAM! Isnt there a lighter GUI which is less of a memory hog? M winnt server guest does better!

My needs for a gui are simple:
* Run Mozilla
* Gui emacs
* Perhaps the redhat updater (im still trying to decide if its worth it)
* Taskbar which allows multiple instances of above apps (so i can view several webpages at once)

Thats it! Anyone have experience with this topic?

Oh, I'm a bit of a Linux newbie (though comfortable with the basics), so be gentle ;)

/Kandir

kandir

Newbie Poster

11 posts since Jul 2003

Reputation Points: 10

Solved Threads: 0

8 Years Ago

0

Gnome and KDE are desktop environments, meaning that they're not just window managers. They also add a whole bunch of their own extras (tools, file managers, tidbits, etc etc etc) to XWindows. Perhaps what you're looking for is something like FVWM or LiteStep (check out fvwm.org or litestep.org, although both should be available on the RedHat install CD).

cscgal

The Queen of DaniWeb

Administrator

19,421 posts since Feb 2002

Reputation Points: 1,474

Solved Threads: 229

8 Years Ago

0

I like blackbox, but I don't think it supports grouping (or even a task manager)

Tekmaven

Software Architect

Moderator

1,274 posts since Feb 2002

Reputation Points: 322

Solved Threads: 28

8 Years Ago

0

Well ok, thanks for the info. I'll check up on your suggestions. Perhaps there's hope yet.

Cheers,
Kandir

kandir

Newbie Poster

11 posts since Jul 2003

Reputation Points: 10

Solved Threads: 0

8 Years Ago

0

use fluxbox or xfce4.

Z28James

Light Poster

44 posts since Feb 2003

Reputation Points: 10

Solved Threads: 1

8 Years Ago

0

My personal recommendation is how I do it:

I run a fairly text-only Linux box, but I install X commands. Then I run X-Win32 (an X server for Windows) on my Windows box. I’m always SSHed into the Linux box, and I have SSH configured to forward X connections, so when I want to run any X app, I just type the command in SSH, and voila, it runs in Windows. Not running the entire KDE or Gnome desktop significantly reduces the amount of memory and other resources the Linux box needs to use to run an X app. It’s probably even better than running a smaller window manager.

I’d be glad to offer details on how to do this if anyone’s interested.

deanpence

Newbie Poster

19 posts since Jul 2003

Reputation Points: 14

Solved Threads: 0

8 Years Ago

0

Eeeeek! Using x-windows to connect to a linux box running on vmware might be a bit too much for my brain deficiency. I have a hard time figuring out whats up and down as it is...

Interesting approach though.

kandir

Newbie Poster

11 posts since Jul 2003

Reputation Points: 10

Solved Threads: 0

8 Years Ago

0

Well, as I said, I don’t use VMWare. I have a separate machine running Linux.

deanpence

Newbie Poster

19 posts since Jul 2003

Reputation Points: 14

Solved Threads: 0

8 Years Ago

0

Can this be done with PuTTY? I know this program supports forwarding of X? Doesn't it?

cscgal

The Queen of DaniWeb

Administrator

19,421 posts since Feb 2002

Reputation Points: 1,474

Solved Threads: 229

8 Years Ago

0

Can this be done with PuTTY? I know this program supports forwarding of X? Doesn't it?

Yes, that’s exactly what I use (when I need to forward X over SSH), actually. You don’t have to forward X connections over SSH, really, but you can. I would definitely do it if forwarding X connections over a high-speed but insecure network. But on your own firewalled LAN, there’s really no reason to use the SSH method. (I know I said that’s what I do, but now that I think of it, I don’t bother to forward connections over SSH. An X-Windows server is all that’s necessary.)

deanpence

Newbie Poster

19 posts since Jul 2003

Reputation Points: 14

Solved Threads: 0

8 Years Ago

0

Can I just use that redhat-supported X server for windows ... gee what's it called again, I forgot ...cygwin!

cscgal

The Queen of DaniWeb

Administrator

19,421 posts since Feb 2002