Hi, and thanks for posting this. I just searched for a similar problem and your post came up, along with thread79952. I'm posting my experience, just in case it would be helpful to anyone else.
Background: We moved to university housing where the internet is provided through their network via 2 wall connections, one in the office, and one in the bedroom. IT Personnel configured our laptops and the wall connections; the office connection worked fine for the Toshiba (running Vista) but the Compaq (running XP SP2) wouldn't connect in the bedroom (I didn't try switching them). Because a neighbor had similar problems and the IT guys said it was the physical connection, we assumed as much for ours.
IT personnel came, checked the physical connection with their own system, and with and without their supplied cable. Their computer browsers worked, so their answer was that the Compaq hardware was the problem, and they suggested reformatting the hard drive to repair it. [I should note here, that the IT personnel gave us two cables when they configured our laptops, one - new - green colored cable, and one - already in use - white cable.]
Not wanting to take so drastic a measure right away (for one problem only), I began searching. I moved the Compaq to the Office and tried the following things:
1) Manually reset winsocks "netsh winsock reset catalog", & rebooted. No change.
2) Checked my firewall settings (Comodo free version); there were no browsers blocked, but just in case, I added rules allowing them. No change.
3) Checked ipconfig [and noted all the values they had added]; then tried to ping it. That was successful, but didn't solve the browser issue.
4) Flushed DNS & rebooted. No change.
5) I ran CCleaner [ http://www.piriform.com/] - both the general cleaner & the registry cleaner [making a backup first] & rebooted. No change.
6) Ran WinSockFix. This cleared out the TCP/IP settings [set it to Obtain IP Automatically], and when I reset them to the IT supplied settings, the browsers worked.
At this point, I moved it to the bedroom. The browsers stopped working, though ping showed a live network connection (just like in the office). I ran WinSockFix at that location, reset the TCP/IP settings, and tried the browsers again without success, though moving the laptop back to the office, the browsers worked.
On a whim, I decided to test the cables. I took the office cable [the white used one] & Compaq laptop back to the bedroom, plugged in, and it worked. To make it more interesting, I took the bedroom cable [the green new one], plugged in the Toshiba laptop in the office, and it worked.
So after all that hassle, it may have been the cable all along. I can't say that for sure, because I believe the IT personnel tried their working cable with the Compaq. Another reminder to check the simple things first.
So, anyone have a suggestion as to why seemingly identical cables would work on one computer and not another?