Its hard to see what has gone wrong if they are all the same. Best to put the working HDD in one of the PCs your having configuration problems with. If it works you know the Windows config is the problem. Other than that its check the motherboards to check everything is plugged in exactly the same, or go throught the BIOS and RAID configuration program. I looked in the manual but it doesn't really say that much.
If one was broken that could be hardware related, but two..... Its really hard to suggest anything more without being there and looking at it. I know how annoying it is, because I spent ages trying to do the same, without sucess because my mobo has two RAID, each with SATA support, and that wasn't immediately apparent.
http://www.asrock.com/Drivers/Manual/P4V88_UM.pdf is the online manual for anyone else who wants to look.