954,359 Members — Technology Publication meets Social Media
Username:
Password:
Lost login information?

Is "I Write Like" a Scam?

0
By sharon fisher on Jul 15th, 2010 1:09 am

I write like Dan Brown.

At least, that's according to the I Write Like site , which was sweeping the Intertubes yesterday (more than 100,000 hits in a single day) as people tried to find out which Famous Writer their deathless prose most resembled. (Brown is the critically slammed author of The DaVinci Code.)

blogger.jpg

The site was put up on July 9 by Coding Robots, a Silicon Valley-based developer, according to the company's blog .

"Currently it analyzes vocabulary (use of words), number of words, commas, and semicolons in sentences, number of sentences with quotation marks and dashes (direct speech)," wrote Dmitry, who claimed authorship.

The site has received some criticisms, with some people wondering whether it's a scam or simply a random result. People who entered text of Famous Writers into the site often found the text attributed to some other Famous Writer -- including, most notably, Famous Writer Margaret Atwood, who found her work most resembled that of Stephen King. "According to the I Write Like analysis, I write like... Ta da! Stephen King! http://bit.ly/bBCMB3 Who knew?" she tweeted .

"“The Raven” is written in the style of William Shakespeare. Shakespeare’s Sonnet 18 is written in the style of Charles Dickens. The first paragraph of Great Expectations is written in the style of P.G. Wodehouse. It seems authors never write in their own styles," commented one reader of the blog.

In addition, the database of authors -- which thus far is secret -- seems to be slanted toward men, more than one commenter complained. "Okay, so this is fun, but why are all the writers men? There are zillions of equally awesome women writers out there. Most of the writers I matched on have written things I’ve enjoyed, but, seriously, where are the women?" Another blogger systematically tried many female authors and writers of color, noting that they all apparently write like white men.

On the other hand, one person ran a series of Xs through it, only to have the program tell them the author, too, wrote like Dan Brown.

Maybe the program is smarter than we think.

The program is an idiot. I copied and pasted the famous Shakespeare quote "that we call a rose, by any other name" and it analysed the author to be Agatha Christie.

Xombi
Newbie Poster
1 post since Jul 2010
Reputation Points: 10
Solved Threads: 0
 

A lot of people have tried a lot of things and gotten a lot of interesting results. :) I wish I could have described them all. Thanks for passing that on.

slfisher
Posting Whiz
Staff Writer
421 posts since May 2008
Reputation Points: 18
Solved Threads: 0
 

Interesting tool. I paste my writings on my blog and write like Bram Stoker! Cool :)

php_noob
Junior Poster in Training
85 posts since Jul 2007
Reputation Points: 10
Solved Threads: 2
 

This article has been dead for over three months

Post: Markdown Syntax: Formatting Help
You
View similar articles that have also been tagged: