944,148 Members | Top Members by Rank

Ad:
  • C Discussion Thread
  • Unsolved
  • Views: 3201
  • C RSS
Mar 29th, 2006
0

hw assignment help on selection & merge sort

Expand Post »
It's from my homework assignment

Question 1)
Based on the O notation, approximately how many swaps and comparisons occur when Selection sort is called on a worst-case array of length 8?

a) 16
b) 64
c) 100
d) 800

Number of swaps = O(n) which is "8" and
Number of comparison = O(n^2) which is "64".

I'm little bit counfused of what the question is asking??? am I suppose to choose more than one answer??


Question 2)
Approximately how many swaps and comparisons occur when Merge Sort is called on a worst-case array of length 8?

a) 8
b) 16
c) 24
d) 64

Number of swaps = O(N log N) or Log2 N which is "3" i think
Number of comparison O(N log N)or Log2 N



Can anybody show me to how to find swaps and comparisons for selection sort & merge sort..please.

thanks
Similar Threads
Reputation Points: 10
Solved Threads: 0
Light Poster
jack223 is offline Offline
27 posts
since Nov 2005
Mar 29th, 2006
0

Re: hw assignment help on selection & merge sort

>Based on the O notation, approximately how many swaps and
>comparisons occur when Selection sort is called on a worst-case array of length 8?
That's very poorly worded. Also, there's no such thing as a worst case for selection sort. The best, average, and worst cases are all identical.
Administrator
Reputation Points: 6442
Solved Threads: 1393
Bad Cop
Narue is offline Offline
11,807 posts
since Sep 2004
Mar 29th, 2006
2

Re: hw assignment help on selection & merge sort

Run the algorithms out by hand in the worst case scenario (you have to figure this out), and while doing so, count the number of swaps and comparisons made. This will be your answer. Troublingly, merge sort would not be implemented with any swapping... and selection sort with 8 elements has a worst case of 28 comparisons, 28 swaps, assuming you move values over by swapping successive pairs of values. (But if moving values is implemented more efficiently, you'll have only 1 instance of what could be called a 'swap'.) Now, 28+1 is closer to the answer 16 than 64, but I'm sure whoever asked this question thinks that '64' is the correct answer.

In conclusion, whoever wrote these questions is nearly an absolute idiot. They want you to go from O(N log N) to 8*log8 = 24? That's lunacy, and that number has nothing to do with the actual number of swaps made. For example, the exact answer to your second problem is 17 comparisons. (Merge sort algorithms generally do not implement any swapping.) I don't blame you for being confused; the questions are written by somebody who does not understand big O notation.

Big O notation says that a value will be no more than a certain _multiple_ of some expression. That multiple could be any positive number imaginable, so big O notation can't be used to get approximations to actual, numerical answers.
Last edited by Rashakil Fol; Mar 29th, 2006 at 6:44 pm. Reason: Slightly toned down insults of teacher, added more information.
Team Colleague
Reputation Points: 1135
Solved Threads: 173
Super Senior Demiposter
Rashakil Fol is offline Offline
2,480 posts
since Jun 2005
Mar 29th, 2006
3

Re: hw assignment help on selection & merge sort

Another way of putting it is that the symbol O(N log N) has exactly the same meaning as O(50N log N). So would the expected answer be 24, or would it be 1200? This is why coming up with any value by plugging numbers into O notation expressions is completely meaningless.
Team Colleague
Reputation Points: 1135
Solved Threads: 173
Super Senior Demiposter
Rashakil Fol is offline Offline
2,480 posts
since Jun 2005
Mar 29th, 2006
0

Re: hw assignment help on selection & merge sort

hmm...i'm still confused!!
so the answer for the first question is "64"??
and the answer for the 2nd question is "24" or "16"?
i hate taking on-line classes....
Reputation Points: 10
Solved Threads: 0
Light Poster
jack223 is offline Offline
27 posts
since Nov 2005
Mar 29th, 2006
2

Re: hw assignment help on selection & merge sort

Why do you care about the answer? The questions themselves are wrong.
Team Colleague
Reputation Points: 1135
Solved Threads: 173
Super Senior Demiposter
Rashakil Fol is offline Offline
2,480 posts
since Jun 2005
Oct 31st, 2010
0
Re: hw assignment help on selection & merge sort
@rashakil fol
how to to count the number of comparison in merge sort.even i am confused with this comparison thing.can u tell me how to count comparison of binary insertion sort.
Reputation Points: 10
Solved Threads: 0
Newbie Poster
poojabi is offline Offline
23 posts
since Aug 2010
Oct 31st, 2010
0
Re: hw assignment help on selection & merge sort
You've replied to a thread that is 4 years old. I doubt the OP is still expecting an answer and will read your post.

Start a new thread for your top, so it will get noticed, and get some answers. A comparison is made whenever you compare the value of one number in the array, with the value of another number in the array.

Can't really say it any clearer than that.
Reputation Points: 416
Solved Threads: 181
Nearly a Posting Virtuoso
Adak is offline Offline
1,463 posts
since Jun 2008

This thread is more than three months old

No one has posted to this discussion for at least three months. Please let old threads die and do not reply to them unless you feel you have something new and valuable to contribute that absolutely must be added to make the discussion complete. Otherwise, please start a new thread in this forum instead.
Message:





About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Acceptable Use Policy
Forum Index | Build Custom RSS Feed


Follow us on Twitter


© 2011 DaniWeb® LLC