I guess music and film production companies (entertainment industry) have persuaded internet service providers to "educate and inform, not "punish" copyright violators. Apparently, one of the ISPs plans on slowing Mbps if necessary. This seems like it is crossing the line because ISP's are only supposed to provide internet service, not directly or indirectly regulate and curtail online practices. It's the principle of the matter that bothers me.
It makes me think of the recent sim card ban on cell phones which makes it illegal to unlock a phone and use it with a different mobile provider than the original one. The argument for the ban is the mobile providers' business model is centered on phone contracts. The argument for lifting the ban is that unlocking a phone doesn't get a person out of a contract, it just gives them other alternatives. Plus, what about people who pay for their phones in full without any sort of contract. Lastly, I remember the SOPA/PIPA scare a couple years ago. That was crazy to think about the potential ramifications. I just hope the internet stays free. That's what makes it so cool. However, big time companies like, for example, Comcast would love to come in through the backdoor and get their hands in the cookie jar.