Cool? yes. Technologically interesting and challenging? yes. Does it do a darn thing to make a computer more useful? Hardly.
Most of that demo shows effects that are eye candy and fluff, but do nothing for usability - they are big time and resource wasters.
Do you really want to drag Linux down to the level of Vista? Most anyone trying to get work done turns off many, if not all, the Aero "features" - gimme a "Windows Classic" look and I'll get work done.
vmanes
Posting Virtuoso
1,914 posts since Aug 2007
Reputation Points: 1,268
Solved Threads: 228
Yeah I have to agree with Vmanes there, it looks great but also a hindrance. Too much going on....
majestic0110
Nearly a Posting Virtuoso
1,328 posts since Oct 2007
Reputation Points: 256
Solved Threads: 72
Meh. Making Linux pretty isn't going to make me accept it as my primary OS. That's like putting a pretty dress on a donkey. At least with Vista the donkey becomes a Mare. Not quite a stallion but--enough with the metaphors already!
scru
Posting Virtuoso
1,629 posts since Feb 2007
Reputation Points: 975
Solved Threads: 140
I was thinking the same thing as vmanes when I watched that. All fluff and zero substance. Totally useless in business except maybe for flashy presentations.
When is someone going to develop a hollagram monitor ? They've been around in sci fi movies for many years.
Ancient Dragon
Retired & Loving It
30,039 posts since Aug 2005
Reputation Points: 5,662
Solved Threads: 2,341
Wha--change the w-world?
Are you being serious?
scru
Posting Virtuoso
1,629 posts since Feb 2007
Reputation Points: 975
Solved Threads: 140
When is someone going to develop a hollagram monitor ? They've been around in sci fi movies for many years.
That would be both super cool, and super useful. Imagine how that might aid in medical imaging, structural design, physical security.... Oh, and the gamers would go wild!
vmanes
Posting Virtuoso
1,914 posts since Aug 2007
Reputation Points: 1,268
Solved Threads: 228
The Linux fanboyz have been saying that they're going to take over the world and that Linux is a viable alternative for everyday use for everyone for a decade at least.
They've been proven false for all that time, and I'm not going to start believing them.
Same as today's Gartner "report" that states that Windows is dead because noone needs an operating system anymore now that almost everything runs on ""the internet".
Clearly written by someone with a political agenda who hasn't got a clue about how computers work.
I read the same kind of reports a decade ago, stating that Windows would "die" within "a few years" because it had got so "bloated" and that Linux would replace it, a younger and leaner operating system (never mind that a standard Linux install comes with tons of crap you don't need, like 500 text editors, 100 window managers, 10 office suits, 5 web browsers, etc. etc., but no decent user interface and configuration system that can be used by your grandmother who doesn't know technical terms.
jwenting
duckman
8,392 posts since Nov 2004
Reputation Points: 1,662
Solved Threads: 337
The closest thing I saw to a hologram was 3-d design monitor that actually moved towards and away from the viewer. The monitor itself did the math to determine where the screen should be. It was incredibly accurate in its giving the 3-d 'look and feel' but mechanically did not generally survive the warranty period.
GrimJack
Posting Maven
2,920 posts since Feb 2004
Reputation Points: 1,448
Solved Threads: 22
Just waiting till Google comes out with their neat no nonsense (NNN) OS.
bumsfeld
Nearly a Posting Virtuoso
1,445 posts since Jul 2005
Reputation Points: 404
Solved Threads: 184
Just waiting till Google comes out with their neat no nonsense (NNN) OS.
Named HAL...
Ezzaral
Posting Genius
15,985 posts since May 2007
Reputation Points: 3,250
Solved Threads: 846
I totally agree with everyone, it is all eye candy but thats not a bad thing. The average user of pc today is mr and ms VANE and they dont give a s**t about usability, they like the bells and whistles.
True, at least at first. I tried that stuff on my laptop about a year, year and a half ago. It got really annoying, so I disabled almost all of the options. Looking back, I ended up quite similar to what Vista has, with some relatively minor differences.My point was: this is cool, not this will change the world and the computer geeks ability to do more. My hope is that people will see the possbilties of Linux and to do that it first needs to appeal to mr. and ms Vane.
The possibilities I see with Linux are still short of it becoming common in the home. It's making good progress, but it's still a little ways from me presenting it to my parents as an alternative that I don't have to go visit them every couple days to show them how to do something or to undo something they've done.
Infarction
Posting Virtuoso
1,580 posts since May 2006
Reputation Points: 683
Solved Threads: 53
Named HAL...
Ah, at last I'll be able to take an axe to Google :)
jwenting
duckman
8,392 posts since Nov 2004
Reputation Points: 1,662
Solved Threads: 337
Google Spider
Junior Poster in Training
54 posts since Feb 2008
Reputation Points: 15
Solved Threads: 2
all looks rather useless to me, except maybe partially rotating windows out of the way when you don't actively need them but would like to monitor them.
jwenting
duckman
8,392 posts since Nov 2004
Reputation Points: 1,662
Solved Threads: 337
Ok this is what is going to make linux appeal to the vista generation
I am 18. I despise fluffy GUIs. On windows i use the standard windows 95 type theme, and on linux i have no effects. i like either no gui, a plain X session, or a gnome desktop with a suitable theme (i do admit ubuntus human theme is nice)
jbennet
Moderator
18,523 posts since Apr 2005
Reputation Points: 1,820
Solved Threads: 599
I am 18. I despise fluffy GUIs. On windows i use the standard windows 95 type theme, and on linux i have no effects. i like either no gui, a plain X session, or a gnome desktop with a suitable theme (i do admit ubuntus human theme is nice)
lol you're different. Which planet? :icon_cheesygrin:
Google Spider
Junior Poster in Training
54 posts since Feb 2008
Reputation Points: 15
Solved Threads: 2