Will a Linux Pad Ever Exist?

khess 0 Tallied Votes 940 Views Share

A lot of people, including me, want one but will a true Linux Pad computer ever exist? I've seen some intriguing prototypes over the years and none more interesting than the Freescale Smartbook but will any of them ever go into mass production? Freescale has the best chance of any that I've seen so far but should it go into production, will it pose any real competition for Apple's iPad? I also have said that I didn't think Apple would ever produce such an animal and, if they did, it would be too expensive for your typical consumer. With the consumer release of the Apple iPad just a breath away, I have to admit that I was wrong about the Apple one. A Linux Pad is, however, a different story.

I want a Linux Pad.

I want it to be just smaller than the size of a standard sheet of paper (8" x 10"), thin (0.5" or less) and inexpensive (<$400 USD). And it should be Moblin-based. Is that too much to ask?

Maybe.

I fear that wholesale component costs will make the device reach into the $500 range, which means that such a device would have to cost consumers close to $700. Much like the iPad.

And it isn't just cost that provides a barrier. The size needs to be decent and such that you can view a more normal amount of text without constant scrolling or paging. Plus, with an aging population, these small screens are not going to sell well among the population with the money to buy them.

You'd think someone would come up with a solution for this.

Someone other than me, that is.

I would pay up to $400 for an electronic device that would be, for the most part, a disposable gadget. And, I'd go into it knowing that a newer, better, more desirable version would show up at two-year intervals. The older, less powerful models would be passed down to the younger generation in my house as toys.

For more than $400, I'll want something that will last three to four years or more with updates and upgrades. And the kids can surf to ebay to purchase their own gently used versions from gadget junkies who've upgraded and can take the loss better than I can.

Will a Linux Pad ever exist? Perhaps only in my mind. Perhaps only on Science Fiction movies and TV shows. Perhaps only as Apple products that aren't using Linux.

Will the Linux Pad of my dreams ever exist? Probably not. Not unless I do it. But I'm not sure how to go about it. How much money would it cost for such an undertaking? Who would build it? Who would mass produce it?

If you have the answers, let me know. I'd like to bring the world a Linux Pad.

Dani AI

Generated

Short answer: yes — but only if a few hard technical and manufacturing problems are accepted or solved. The thread already shows there were real prototypes and community interest, and those proof‑points matter; a sustainable, <$400 Linux pad needs the right SoC, open drivers, and a realistic manufacturing plan. As history shows, Moblin was folded into MeeGo in 2010 (the mobile Linux landscape consolidated early on), so pick an OS stack that still has active upstream work rather than chasing a deprecated distro. (intel.com)

The technical blockers are predictable: GPU/display/touch drivers, power management (suspend/resume), and upstream kernel support for a chosen SoC. In recent years open drivers have improved (for example the Panfrost/Lima efforts for Mali GPUs), which makes modern ARM SoCs far friendlier to mainline Linux than they were a decade ago. Also plan for a standard embedded boot/board flow (U‑Boot + device tree) so you can upstream fixes instead of maintaining a custom fork. (idr.pages.freedesktop.org)

Manufacturing economics are the other hard wall. Custom enclosures and injection tooling create big NRE/tooling steps; simple prototype tooling can be a few thousand dollars, production tooling commonly runs into tens of thousands and up depending on complexity — those costs get amortized over volume, so MOQ and channel matter to hit consumer price targets. If the goal is <$400 retail, expect to lean on commodity panels, a low‑cost SoC with mainline support, and tight BOM engineering. (rpproto.com)

Practical next steps (minimal risk path): 1) pick a widely supported SoC (one with mainline kernel support), 2) prototype with an off‑the‑shelf dev board + compatible LCD/touch panel, 3) upstream drivers and device‑tree so maintainability is realistic, 4) pilot small runs (soft tooling or rapid tooling) to validate ergonomics and battery, then 5) scale with an ODM/CM or crowdfunding once BOM and manufacturing quotes are concrete. The community interest you and others showed makes a niche Linux pad feasible — but expect the economics to dictate timing and target market (enthusiasts/developers first, mainstream later).

c27 0 Newbie Poster

Hi, I dunno about Moblin, but I am using one now for 2 weeks. It runs Ubuntu, and I love it. It's called the Touch Book, and it also functions as a pad. I get 10 hrs of battery life from it. It is not a lightning bolt, but for what I need it, it's fine for me.
Having said that, it plays my xvid files just fine.
It multitasks quite well, and came out way before the iPad.

khess 95 Practically a Master Poster

Would you mind providing a link to the website?

pelleger 0 Newbie Poster

The home page for the company making the touch book is
http://www.alwaysinnovating.com/home/index.htm

sinistral 0 Newbie Poster

Linux Journal has a review of the TouchBook (not the very latest hardware you would buy if you ordered one now):

carl_000 0 Newbie Poster

Not only does it exist, it'll also make the iPad look like an expensive toy: http://www.notionink.in/index.php

BTW, I am not affiliated with the company in any way, but I am truly impressed with this product.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.