Hi everyone, I'm beginning to learn about progamming and I'm currently working through the seminal 'C Programming Language' which is excellent, but I have a problem regarding functions.

My understanding of functions in C is that they return a value. For example:

x = func(a, b);

...would set x to the value returned by 'func'.

But it seems that the variables used within a function are local to that function, and do not alter the variables in the original function that called them.

However the following example seems to show the values of the called function making changes in the calling function's variables, and which are then passed to another function.

main() {
	int len, max;
	char line[1000];
	char longest[1000];

	max = 0

	while ((len = getline(line, 1000)) > 0)
		if (len > max) {
			max = len;
			copy(longest, line)
			}
}

int getline(char s[], int lim) {
	int c, i;

	for (i=0; i<lim-1 && (c=getchar()) != EOF && c != '\n'; ++i)
		s[i] = c;
	if (c == '\n') {
		s[i] = c;
		++i;
		}
	s[i] = '\0'
	return i;
}

void copy(char to[], char from[]) {
	int i;

	i = 0;
	while ((to[i] = from[i]) != '\0')
		++i;
}

In other words, 'line' is passed by main to function 'getline' as an empty character array. Getline fills a local array, s, with the characters of the next line and returns the total length of the line to main.

But somehow the character array 'line' has been filled with the contents of the array 's', because line may then be passed to 'copy', which fills another array, to, with its contents.

In contrast in a program such as this:

main() {
	int a, b;

	a = 1;
	b = 2;
	c = func(a, b);
	printf("%d %d %d", a, b, c);
}

int func(int aa, int bb) {
	aa = 4;
	bb = 5;
	return 0;
}

...will output:
1 2 0

because the variables aa and bb are local to func, and do not affect a and b, their analogues in main.

So, it seems that an array can be passed to a function, and this function may fill the original array by filling its local array.

Is this right? Or is there some property of functions and/or arrays I've failed to understand?

I apologise if there are mistakes in the code or this is an inanely stupid question. If anyone can help me I'll be exceptionally grateful!

Thanks!
Ben

It all depends upon how the functions are defined. Look up 'passing by value' vs. 'passing by reference'.

My understanding of functions in C is that they return a value.

not all functions return a value. Any function defined as such:

void functionName() or void functionName( parameters....)

returns nothing.

It all depends upon how the functions are defined. Look up 'passing by value' vs. 'passing by reference'.

I guess person is talking in context of 'C'...and in 'C' there is no pass by reference...there's only pass by value

That links explains what i said...that there is no pass by reference...there are so many things like this which you can simulate and which is not in the language...so no point discussing about this issue.

Note:And by the way the substitute technique mentioned in the link is also pass by value i.e. passing address of an object by value.

address of array is passed automatically and the changes will be seen back but not in case of second example

This article has been dead for over six months. Start a new discussion instead.