Member Avatar for Ancient Dragon

Shouldn't his account be retired? He passed away a couple years ago, I think it's time for DaniWeb to retire his account and move on. I see his name in such places as Endorsements, which don't really mean anything for him any more.

  • 7 Contributors
  • 10 Replies
  • 400 Views
  • 1 Week Discussion Span
  • Latest Post Latest Post by TrustyTony
Member Avatar for mike_2000_17

What does "retire his account" mean? I guess it should mean that it is deactivated in the sense that it won't "participate" anymore (e.g., doesn't show up on endorsements, cannot send him PMs, etc.). But obviously, all past posts and stuff should remain, probably also the user profile (maybe with a eulogy-like notice).

Member Avatar for Ancient Dragon

Yes, Mike, that is what I mean.

Member Avatar for happygeek

What DaniWeb needs is a 'memorial account' option, similar to Facebook, perhaps?

Member Avatar for <M/>

similar to Facebook, perhaps?

i didn't know facebook has such a thing.

What DaniWeb needs is a 'memorial account' option

I read a couple of Dave Sinkula's posts, he has some pretty good posts... why not create a memorial page for him...

But how would you know if a Daniwebber is no longer living...? Wouldn't that be kind of challenging to figure out?

Member Avatar for Ancient Dragon

We only found out about Dave because another member who knew him personally told us. No one is asking anyone at DaniWeb to periodically search world-wide death records for all 1,000,000+ members, that would be just stupid. A memorial account for known people is a good idea.

Member Avatar for deceptikon

He passed away a couple years ago, I think it's time for DaniWeb to retire his account and move on.

No offense toward Dave's memory in any way as he was easily one of my best friends online, but why would we need to retire his account? How is it different from any other member that suddenly stops posting?

I guess it should mean that it is deactivated in the sense that it won't "participate" anymore (e.g., doesn't show up on endorsements, cannot send him PMs, etc.). But obviously, all past posts and stuff should remain, probably also the user profile (maybe with a eulogy-like notice).

There's no way to do that presently, we don't make a distinction between active accounts an inactive accounts except through hard deletion (though deletion does a lot of what "retiring" seems to be). And I'd be against deleting Dave's account, for personal reasons.

What DaniWeb needs is a 'memorial account' option, similar to Facebook, perhaps?

That I can get behind. Something to mark an account as being special in the hearts of the community even though it's no longer active.

But how would you know if a Daniwebber is no longer living...? Wouldn't that be kind of challenging to figure out?

It depends on the cause of death and how friendly the member is with other members. In Dave's case it was advanced cancer. While things progressed shockingly fast, there was plenty of advance warning that he'd likely not make it. We knew because he told those close to him and also blogged about his experience.

Edited by deceptikon
Member Avatar for ddanbe

You could delete an account of a member, but what about the answers he/she gave in all the different threads? I'm in with deceptikon here, you can't delete. Unless you do a "tabula rasa" and start up daniweb all over again, but I guess that is totaly out of question.

Member Avatar for deceptikon

You could delete an account of a member, but what about the answers he/she gave in all the different threads?

Thread continuity isn't affected when an account is deleted, it just shows up as a deleted account. While we could delete Dave's account without any negative effect, I'd be against it on principle.

Member Avatar for ddanbe

@deceptikon: Agreed! and thanks for the info.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.