In-depth tests reveal worst antivirus product is no longer OneCare


Independent Austrian antivirus testing outfit AV Comparatives has a reputation for going the extra mile when putting products through their paces. Something that Microsoft discovered to its cost earlier in the year when, rather embarrassingly, its flagship OneCare antivirus product managed to finish last and fail to get a highly sought after AV Comparatives certification of any sort.

Things have improved for the Seattle giants since then, and in the latest round of tests for which the results have just been published, OneCare no longer languishes at the bottom of the heap. Microsoft has only moved up 3 places into 14th position, but it beat some rather well thought of names in the AV industry in so doing. In 15th place came Kaspersky Labs AV v6.02, just above Microworld eScan Antivirus 8 (which I have to admit to have never heard of before now) and the newly crowned worst antivirus product is Grisoft AVG AntiMalware v7.5 which managed to detect only 8% of new samples, returned 'many' false positives while registering slow for its on-demand scanning speed. A very poor result which saw it fail to get certificated, unlike Microsoft OneCare which can now claim to have reached a standard level by detecting just 18% of the 20522 new threats thrown at it. Not really that great, though, is it?

Certainly not when compared to the likes of standard certificated AVIRA AntiVir PE Premium 7 which racked up an impressive 71% detection rate although it too scored many false positives. The other product to hit that 71% detection rate failed to get certificated at all, Fortinet FortiClient 3 performed amazingly badly in this regard. While the FP range for all other products on test was between 0 (Symantec Norton Anti Virus) and 36 (Doctor Web Dr.Web 4), Fortinet rated at 'more than 1000' which is truly shocking.

According to security researcher Andreas Clementi at AV Comparatives, the overall winner and recipient of an Advanced+ certification with a detection rate of 68%, only 2 false positives and a fast scanning speed was ESET NOD32 AntiVirus 2.7

Member Avatar
Davey Winder

I've been a freelance word punk for more than two decades and for the last few years an Editorial Fellow at Dennis Publishing. Along the way I have been honoured with a Technology Journalist of the Year award, and three Information Security Journalist of the Year awards. Most humbling, though, was the Enigma Award for 'lifetime contribution to IT security journalism' bestowed on me in 2011. As well as working for DaniWeb I have been a Contributing Editor with PC Pro (the best selling IT magazine in the UK) for twenty years.


The link to the PDF report results in a 404 error for me.


Turns out you cannot link directly to the report file but have to go in through the main AV Comparatives home page and navigate to it from there. Most annoying.

I have removed the dead PDF link from the posting, thatnks for the heads up!


im just dropping by,nice post!


However, company's name is ESET, not ESIT ;)


Thanks, well spotted and now corrected.


hi, i want to install nod32 2.7 in my pc can you give me the full verson of the software, thank you, my e-mail is


Enjoy surfing the internet for hours at a time.
If you're anything like me then you enjoy surfing the internet for hours at a time. There is so much information available I just seem to get wrapped up in it all. Of course, this means picking up bugs that can literally ruin my computer and cause it to run too slow. To take care of my PC I've been searching for a good scan to keep it bug free. I tried many different ones but I like Orbasoft Antispyware the best. With the antispyware solution from Orbasoft ( I get one of the best scans I've ever used at a great low price. This is exactly what I've been searching for.

Isn't it about time forums rewarded their contributors?

Earn rewards points for helping others. Gain kudos. Cash out. Get better answers yourself.

It's as simple as contributing editorial or replying to discussions labeled or OP Kudos

This is an OP Kudos discussion and contributors may be rewarded
Start New Discussion
View similar articles that have also been tagged: