Dear China, Microsoft Wants to Charge You for Air Too

khess 0 Tallied Votes 256 Views Share

A new deal struck between Microsoft and its Linux ally Novell (SuSE Linux) is headed for mainland China. Microsoft claims now that Linux violates 42 of its patents (down from over 200 a year ago) and that purchasing SuSE Linux will indemnify Linux users from lawsuits for patent infringement.

Thanks Microsoft but no thanks.

Who knew that when Novell signed their pact with the Evil Empire that it would mean an all-out attack on emerging markets like China, India, and Brazil? Hey Microsoft, haven’t you heard that the median income in China is about $3,400 per year and in India, it’s about $2,000? China is also primary target for Microsoft extortion because it’s at the top of their software piracy list.

I think it’s odd that Microsoft is pushing Linux to the Chinese instead of its flagship Vista software. They hope to convert Linux users—who are violating their patents—to SuSE Linux.

The scenario goes something like this:

Microsoft: Hi, we’re Microsoft and Novell and we want you to buy our Operating System. It’s Linux and it protects you from violating our patents.

China: But we get Linux free under the GPL. Moreover, we rip off your software anyway because we don’t recognize or care about your patents or copyrights.

Microsoft: But we’re Microsoft and you should compensate us for using our patented technology. Purchasing SuSE Linux will do that for you.

China: We’re China. We don’t care.

Microsoft: You can’t use Linux for free. It isn’t…isn’t American!

China: Hey, what about Vista? Even our pirated copies don’t work. When are you going to fix that?

Microsoft: <No Response> Ballmer explodes into a million tiny annoying bits of non-environmentally friendly fluff.

Microsoft ultimately responds by obtaining a patent for oxygen.

Dani AI

Generated

Short primer and fact check for the thread: Microsoft’s public flap about Linux and patents was real, but the numbers and the deal’s scope are often misunderstood. In a May 2007 media round Microsoft executives said open-source software touched “235” Microsoft patents (the company broke that down as 42 for the kernel), but they did not publish a list of specific patents. The statement stirred wide coverage and pushback from the free‑software community. Wired coverage of the Fortune story.

What the Novell–Microsoft agreement actually did (announced in November 2006) was a commercial, enterprise-facing arrangement: Microsoft bought SUSE support “certificates” to distribute to customers, the companies agreed to mutual covenants not to sue certain customers, and significant money changed hands. The legal/patent element was a limited covenant tied to Novell’s SUSE Enterprise program rather than a blanket license for all Linux distributions. The deal and its financials are summarized in contemporaneous coverage and Novell’s SEC filings. and CRN summary of the patent/financial points.

Practical implications for the points raised by , , and : the arrangement was aimed at enterprise buyers (Microsoft marketed certificates and listed large customers), not at people downloading GPL‑licensed kernels for free; the “42” number was the piece of Microsoft’s public breakdown that referred to the kernel specifically; and the Free Software Foundation and others pushed GPLv3 language to prevent selective patent covenants from undermining the license. See Novell/Microsoft customer announcements and the Novell Q&A transcript for how Novell and community lawyers explained the covenant’s limits. Microsoft/NOVELL customer announcement and Novell IRC/Q&A transcript on the deal.

Takeaway: for individual desktop users the practical risk did not suddenly change; for organizations that require legal indemnity or predictable risk profiles, the real choice was commercial — buy supported SUSE (or another indemnified offering) or perform a legal risk assessment before deploying community builds in mission‑critical systems.

scru 909 Posting Virtuoso Featured Poster

How did this make the front page?

blud 82 Linux Reject Moderator

Anyone find it odd that they only have '42' violations?

Microsoft has found the secret to the universe.

Shackbase 0 Junior Poster in Training

Seriously? Bashing Microsoft is so 2004.

--Tone

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.