Some press releases grab your attention for all the wrong reasons, although from the PR perspective if it has grabbed my attention it has obviously worked. One such scurried across my desktop the other day: Logitech rolls out its coolest mouse ever, the headline proclaimed.

Oh crikey, thought I, here we go again. Another day another mouse and another press release desperately trying to convince me that my mouse is not any good and this mouse will change the way I work. It is a new mouse revolution, I was promised enthusiastically. I can fly through long documents with hyper-fast scrolling I was assured, hundreds of pages with a flick of my finger indeed. A precision scroll wheel that will spin freely for up to seven seconds they announced, forgetting to explain why this should be of any interest to me at all. I later discovered this means it can apparently scroll through 10,000 pages in that time. But hey, it is fast, smart and fully loaded according to Logitech so it must be worth investigating further.

Therefore, I did.

Apparently, I am informed, the average person scrolls the mouse wheel a whopping 26 feet during an eight hour day, which I can quite believe as I have worn out numerous mice and the scroll wheel is usually the first thing I kill. As an aside, I also kill keyboards with alarming regularity, either completely removing any trace of key markings or more often any trace of key movement. Peripheral build quality ain’t what it used to be. Anyway, back on track, and the mighty mouse. The MX Revolution, to be precise, although a slightly smaller VX version is available for laptop use as well. It is a typical Logitech styled piece of high tech sculpture that, typically, left handers will find frustrating.

Not being a lefty, that does not worry me as much as the fact that it is a wireless, laser, electronically controlled scroll wheel ratcheted, seven-buttoned monster.

Look Logitech, and anyone else who might be reading this and has any input (excuse the pun) into the business of designing mice: I only want two buttons and a scroll wheel, that is it, I do not need any more. I do not need some battery dependant wireless device either, not considering that a cable-connected mouse has never let me down just when I needed it most. Moreover, I certainly do not need a mouse that requires me to RTFM before I can use the thing, OK! For crying out loud, the MX Revolution automatically switches between motor and manual mode, depending upon the application you are using, and will either go into hyper-scrolling free-spinning wheel mode on its own accord or if you push and click the wheel in the right fashion. I have enough difficulty remembering what the left and right buttons do half the time, and would fear for my sanity with such a device. Do I really need, for example, a one-touch search function whereby I can click on a highlighted word to launch Google?

Oh, and I guess I should mention that there is a second scroll wheel, should the hyper-fast super whoopy doo main one not be enough and you grow a few extra fingers at some point.

In addition, do I really need all this to the tune of, wait for it, a hundred bucks?

Well yes, according to Logitech’s vice president of product marketing for retail pointing devices, Ashish Arora who says “by giving people the option of using a free-spinning scroll wheel, Logitech has addressed a source of pain for computer users, who previously had to continuously move their index finger to scroll through long documents.”

Well no, according to the professional writer who prefers keyboard shortcuts where possible and makes use of either an optical trackball device on the desktop or a teeny two buttoned, one wheeled, USB connected retractable cabled optical travel mouse for laptop use (don’t even get me started about touch pads or nipples.)

Sorry Logitech, but as far as this mouse being revolutionary, I smell a rat...

As Editorial Director and Managing Analyst with IT Security Thing I am putting more than two decades of consulting experience into providing opinionated insight regarding the security threat landscape for IT security professionals. As an Editorial Fellow with Dennis Publishing, I bring more than two decades of writing experience across the technology industry into publications such as Alphr, IT Pro and (in good old fashioned print) PC Pro. I also write for SC Magazine UK and Infosecurity, as well as The Times and Sunday Times newspapers. Along the way I have been honoured with a Technology Journalist of the Year award, and three Information Security Journalist of the Year awards. Most humbling, though, was the Enigma Award for 'lifetime contribution to IT security journalism' bestowed on me in 2011.

11 Years
Discussion Span
Last Post by happygeek

It does have two scroll wheels as well one on the top and on the side whic h would seem like a major point to make.


Presumably if you're in a position where you are faced with reading a 10,000 page document, chances are that you need to READ the document. Any technology that allows me to quickly skip massive chunks of this document would seem to be more of a detriment than benefit.


What if you are editing it?

I remain unconvinced that a hyper-scrolling, free-spinning, motorised mouse wheel is the way to best achieve quickly getting from point A to B in a long document though.

Have something to contribute to this discussion? Please be thoughtful, detailed and courteous, and be sure to adhere to our posting rules.