newsguy 30 The News Guy

Facebook, home of the 104 year old Frisbee Queen, would appear to have taken a disliking to large parts of Wales. You know, that rather lovely country which borders England and forms part of the United Kingdom. Wales even has a devolved Government in the Welsh Assembly, something the Welsh fought long and hard to get. No wonder, then, people are more than a little bit annoyed at discovering that Facebook now informs the world they live in England.

It seems that people who live in places such as Cardiff and Swansea, very definitely in Wales, now find Facebook giving their location as Cardiff, England for example.

More than 8000 angry Facebookers have started a protest group to get their profiles changed back to show them as living in Wales, but so far Facebook itself is remaining oddly quiet on the matter. Some Welsh users, so perturbed at being thought of as English have even started choosing other towns with the same name on the other side of the planet such as Cardiff, Australia.

Let's hope they do not try asking questions about their homeland of Wolfram Alpha, the much hyped computational data engine. Ask it what the population of Wales is and it reckons the answer is 5956, using an estimate from 2004. Now I know it is a relatively small part, population-wise, of the United Kingdom but last time I looked it up (which was 10 seconds ago on Google) the actual number of people living there was 2.9 million.

Dani AI

Generated

Good catch by — this thread touches two different problems that look similar on the surface but have different causes and fixes: place-tagging on social networks, and stale or mis-parsed data in computational engines.

Social sites use a curated place database and an auto-complete match. When a town name is ambiguous, the suggestion you pick determines the country/region attached to your profile. If the correct country/region does not appear when editing your profile location, try typing the town plus the country (for example, "TownName, Wales") and choose the matching suggestion. If no correct match appears, remove the incorrect entry, reopen the place selector, and submit a report via the platform’s Help/Report tools (see the Facebook Help Center for the current reporting path). Include a screenshot and the exact text you typed — that makes the issue actionable.

Computational engines aggregate many data sources and can show an out-of-date or mis-attributed value. Always check the result panel for source and date metadata, then verify major figures against an official statistics agency such as the Office for National Statistics or a reliable encyclopedia entry (for quick checks, see Wales — Wikipedia). If a Wolfram|Alpha result looks wrong, use the site's About/contact options () to report the specific query, the displayed result, and an authoritative source for the correct figure.

Practical checklist: include the country/region in place queries, keep screenshots and the exact query text when reporting, and always cite the source and date when quoting population or political boundaries.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.