Eek! Assemblyman Claims Terrorists Could Use Google Earth to Find Buildings

slfisher 0 Tallied Votes 354 Views Share

Remember last fall, when people were terrified that pedophiles were using Google Streetview to find parks and schools so they could more readily find their young victims?

Apparently a California legislator has been listening to them, or someone like them.

Last month, California Assemblyman Joel Anderson, R-El Cajon, introduced a bill to limit the amount of detail someone could see on screen using online mapping tools such as Google Earth, Microsoft Virtual Earth, and Google Streetview. It also calls for fines of up to $250,000 per day.

In particular, the bill -- which has been languishing in the Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports, Tourism, and Internet Media since March 4, and won't be heard before March 27, if then -- says the mapping tools can't display a school or place of worship, or a government or medical building or facility, unless those photographs or images have been blurred.

Anderson's concern (expressed in his "Google Earth Should Stop Helping Hate Groups & Terrorists") is that terrorists will use the software's images to decide where to put bombs.

Aside from the fact that, were the bill to be implemented, all terrorists would have to do is look for blurry pictures and plant bombs there, Anderson's bill has the same flaws and inappropriately blames technology in the same way that the Pedophiles on Streeview did: Numerous other sources of the same information exist -- including other online maps, paper maps, telephone books, and even public signs.

On the other hand, maybe public buildings need protection after all. In the U.K., a man reportedly used Google Earth to pinpoint old buildings with lead roofs, in order to steal the material. His 30 thefts netted him a dollar value of more than 100,000 U.K. pounds' worth of the material.

Dani AI

Generated

Short expert summary and practical next steps (adds context to and )

The core issue here isn’t a single website — it’s public data. High-resolution views come from many places (commercial satellite vendors, aerial surveys, government archives and user photos), so removing detail from one map only reduces, not eliminates, availability. (doc.arcgis.com)

Real-world misuse has happened. Courts and police reports show thieves and burglar rings using online maps and Street View to pick targets, so the threat is plausible even if blaming one product is simplistic. Mapping services do offer takedown/blurring tools (for example, Google’s Street View “Report a problem” form); note that provider-applied blurs are generally permanent once published. (indianexpress.com)

Practical checklist for site owners and facility managers

  • Inventory what’s public: check Street View, satellite basemaps, business listings and social-media photos.
  • Ask providers to blur or remove sensitive imagery (use each provider’s reporting tools). ()
  • Stop adding location metadata: strip EXIF/GPS from photos before uploading and turn off camera geotagging on devices. (us.norton.com)
  • Coordinate with local law enforcement and national partners for threat assessment and reporting; use official reporting channels if there’s a specific threat. (fbi.gov)
  • Harden the site physically and operationally: barriers, lighting, CCTV angles, staff awareness and restricted-access signage.

Policy note: blanket censorship is blunt. Some governments have used legal controls to limit imagery in narrow cases (one historic example is the Kyl–Bingaman matter), but policy is complex and can’t fully erase commercial or user-collected imagery. A more effective path combines provider takedowns, digital hygiene, law-enforcement coordination and targeted physical hardening. (spacenews.com)

Short, practical steps beat sensational headlines.

airbourne 29 Junior Poster

I'm stunned that people like Joel Anderson can hold a public office. I'm even more stunned when people behave ignorantly like Joel and manage to get RE-elected. It doesn't matter your political affiliation, I just wish people would recognize stupid when they see it and stop voting them back into office.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.