Member Avatar for Bitwise

Having launched an online computer magazine just a few days ago, I've been deluged with requests from readers who want to be able to leave feedback (to be honest, I hadn't expected so many people to visit so soon and I wasn't prepared to deal with this).

What are my options? In the long term I shall probably open a forum but I don't want to rush into that. I think ideally something with a blog-like interface but with the facility to allow any reader to post might be useful. In essence, I want to have some way for readers to leave a 'letter to the editor'. I realise they can do that by email (it's what they are doing at the moment). But is there some slicker way of providing this feature (which also avoids clogging up my email in tray ;) )?

best wishes
Huw

  • 2 Contributors
  • 2 Replies
  • 134 Views
  • 18 Hours Discussion Span
  • Latest Post Latest Post by Bitwise

Dani AI

Generated

Short-term ways to capture reader "letters" without the full admin load that is worried about — and that still leave room to move to a larger community solution later, as suggested.

Create a single, moderated "Letters to the Editor" submission flow. Keep the public side simple (one page with recent published letters). Keep the inbox off-line: submissions go into a small queue (database or Google Form), marked "pending" until reviewed. Basic fields: display name, subject, body, and a required contact email that is not shown publicly. Always sanitize user content, log submitter IP and timestamp, and keep a CSV/JSON export option so migration to a future system is easy. Quick tools: use Google Forms to stand up a queue in minutes; add reCAPTCHA or a honeypot field to cut spam.

If you want a faster, richer feature set with less custom work, a hosted comment service can get you moderation tools, spam filtering, and social sign-in immediately. That buys time but introduces third-party JS/privacy trade-offs — evaluate that trade-off before you commit. Example provider: Disqus.

Practical next steps and governance to reduce workload and legal exposure: publish a short submission policy (what you will/won't publish), require consent to publish, set a small moderation SLA (e.g., review once or twice daily), recruit one trusted volunteer if traffic spikes, and enable automated spam checks (Akismet or similar). Keep an eye on defamation/privacy risks and be prepared to remove content on request. These controls let you filter the signal from noise now and scale into a full discussion board later with minimal rework.

Recommended Answers

All 2 Replies

Member Avatar for Dani

I really think it's time to open a forum. You'll be happier in the long run if you do. Blogs aren't so great as a back and forth channel of communication, and it seems you'll end up wanting to convert blog comments to a forum down the line anyways. Remember, you can always start with just one or two forums and then expand as the site grows. Forum software will also allow you to put together a nice growing memberlist right off the bat.

The only thing that I would be careful of right now is liability. You want to make sure that no slanderous comments are being posted about hosting companies. You also want to make sure that one host isn't going to post negative feedback about a competitor.

While I do think it's time to open a forum - especially if your visitors are already expressing that they want to share with other visitors - I think you should take a little bit of time to plan out exactly how you want to set up the forum to ensure it remains a pleasant, spam-free, slander-free place.

There's no time like the present! Good luck.

Member Avatar for Bitwise

Thanks. This is what I had planned to do over time. However, as I said, I wasn't ready to deal with such an influx of visitors quite so soon after going online and I'm concerned that if I jump in and put a forum online too quickly, I may end up causing more problems than I solve!

I have run one very small board before and moderated another (both phpBB) so I know the basics of getting one up and running. I also realise a) how much time it takes (when I have plenty of other things to do at the present time) and b) that if I get the structure of the forums wrong, it's going to be difficult to fix after people have already been posting for a while.

As this board is obviously quite big now, I'm sure you must have made a few mistakes along the way. Maybe you could make a lits of the pitfalls to avoid when setting one up....? ;)

best wishes
Huw

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.