Are women forced to have sex with strangers after being pimped on Craigslist?

happygeek 0 Tallied Votes 313 Views Share

That's what Cook County Sheriff Thomas Dart is claiming as part of a federal lawsuit by the Illinois lawman. The lawsuit is seeking a ban on one part of Craigslist, namely the Erotic Services section, which is accused of acting as a clearing house for prostitution.

According to The Times Dart is arguing that Craigslist facilitates prostitution because it has not put into place any method to block those who blatantly offer sex for money.

Sheriff Dart, speaking at a press conference, insisted that "Craigslist is the single largest source of prostitution in the nation" and that "Missing children, runaways, abused women and women trafficked in from foreign countries are routinely forced to have sex with strangers because they're being pimped on Craigslist."

Dart claims to have given Craigslist every chance to clean up its act, and to have made many pleas for it to close the Erotic Services section, before resorting to the lawsuit which comes just four months after another lawsuit was settled promising to bring in new rules on the use of the site for prostitution services. The sheriff reckons that in just two years his department has made at least 200 arrests for juvenile pimping, human trafficking and other offences which have been linked to Craigslist in some way.

Craigslist is a hugely successful site, established in 1995 by Craig Newmark and now attracting half a billion visitors every month. A spokesperson told The Times that "...any misuse of the site is not tolerated on Craigslist."

Dani AI

Generated

This thread republishes a 2009 news item shared by (and critiqued by and defended by ). The short, verifiable history is different from the sensational headline: Cook County’s sheriff did bring a federal suit over Craigslist’s adult/erotic listings, but the case was dismissed by the U.S. District Court in October 2009—the judge treated Craigslist as an online intermediary and relied on CDA Section 230 protections while noting law‑enforcement had used listings to make arrests. (case-law.vlex.com)

After the lawsuit and mounting pressure from multiple state attorneys general, Craigslist changed how it handled adult ads and then removed the U.S. “adult services” area in September 2010; meanwhile many ads migrated to other sites (notably Backpage). That migration and Backpage’s practices later drew a major federal investigation, indictments, and guilty pleas/convictions. For a concise timeline and primary documents, consult the court opinion and the DOJ case materials. (wired.com)

Bottom line for readers: the underlying harms described in the original article—trafficking, pimping, and coerced sex—are real criminal problems; the legal question is whether a classifieds operator can be held civilly liable for third‑party postings. In 2009 the answer in federal court was “no” under Section 230, but Congress narrowed parts of that immunity with FOSTA‑SESTA in 2018, changing the legal landscape for platforms and enforcement. Anyone following this topic should read the district opinion, the post‑2010 migration story, and the 2018 legislation to understand how policy and prosecution evolved. (case-law.vlex.com)

For context and credible sources: the district court opinion (Dart v. Craigslist), EFF’s case summary, contemporary reporting on Craigslist’s policy changes, and the Department of Justice statements on Backpage provide accurate, contemporaneous records of what happened and why the headline and the legal record diverge. (eff.org)

Rashakil Fol 978 Super Senior Demiposter Team Colleague

How can anybody rate this an "excellent" article? This is linkbaiting trash.

pgaik 0 Newbie Poster

its a accurate news story. get a life.

happygeek 2,411 Most Valuable Poster Team Colleague Featured Poster

Thanks for the support. It is what it is, a news story. Sure the headline is meant to attract readers, that's kind of the point.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.