Microsoft takes the gay out of gaming on Xbox Live

newsguy 0 1K Views

The Consumerist is currently running a about how a gamer was first harassed by other players and then booted off Xbox Live by Microsoft. Her crime? Admitting she was a lesbian in her gamer profile. According to the report she was harassed online by other gamers and when she complained to Microsoft was told that gamers found her sexual orientation offensive and her suspension stood.

Microsoft that the terms and conditions of use for Xbox Live forbid the creation of a gamertag or use of text in other profile fields "that include comments that look, sound like, stand for, hint at, abbreviate, or insinuate content of a potentially sexual nature."

Which is probably why gamer Richard Gaywood also found his gamertag suspended.

Is it just me that finds the Microsoft position somewhat bizarre? On the one hand it says that it takes harassment of any kind "very seriously" and strongly encourages members to report "inappropriate behaviour" so it can be investigated. Yet at the same time seems to be harassing the gay and lesbian community with its own actions.

Dani AI

Generated

This thread highlights a recurring moderation problem: rules intended to block sexual content can be written or applied so broadly that they end up penalizing people for stating personal identity. started the discussion about a player who reported harassment and then had her profile suspended; posters like , , and correctly point out the tension between enforcing civility and protecting users who simply say who they are. That tension is a common failure mode in automated filters and in inconsistent human review.

Practical steps if this happens to you or someone you support:

  • Preserve everything: screenshots, exact profile text, timestamps, message IDs and any enforcement emails or case numbers.
  • File formal reports and keep the confirmation or case reference. Use the official appeals channel rather than only forum posts.
  • Appeal calmly and precisely: quote the exact profile wording, attach evidence of harassment, state what action you want (reinstatement, explanation), and request a human review.
  • Reduce exposure while the case is open: block offenders, tighten profile visibility, and avoid provocative language in appeal text.
  • If the response is unclear or inadequate, document dates and follow an escalation path (support supervisors, platform complaint forms, or consumer advocacy), staying factual.

Platforms should give clear definitions and a reliable human-review appeals path. Policies and procedures change over time, so check the current enforcement and appeals pages for up-to-date steps.

Member Avatar for jbennet
jbennet 1,618 Most Valuable Poster

"content of a potentially sexual nature"

so posting your sexual preferance is indeed against the rules

Member Avatar for Rashakil Fol
Rashakil Fol 978 Super Senior Demiposter

so posting your gender is indeed against the rules

Member Avatar for happygeek
happygeek 2,411 Most Valuable Poster

Yeah, but is it fair that Richard Gaywood gets his gamertag suspended because his name is 'offensive' to the small minded? Is it fair that Microsoft support tells a woman that people find it 'offensive' that she is a lesbian?

Those, I think, are the issues here.

Microsoft seems to be having a think () about the whole issue, now admitting that it has an "inelegant" banning policy and is going to investigate the Xbox Live policy that caused the problem.

Member Avatar for pgaik
pgaik 0 Newbie Poster

why cant i say i am gay on xbox libe? it is stupid ruling and discriminates against gays.

Member Avatar for rzahir101
rzahir101 0 Newbie Poster

I think i am gay on xbox live. Thats the reality. ok.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.

Edit Preview