The million dollar Xbox

newsguy 0 Tallied Votes 439 Views Share

The cost of an Xbox 360 is dropping like a brick, which is just as well considering with the Microsoft games console. In fact the whole Red Rings of Death thing has led to some frustrated users .

Jesse Maiman, a Yale University student, is also going to court over an Xbox 360 but his lawsuit is not against Microsoft and his console is not broken as far as he knows. It is, however, missing. Maiman boarded a US Airways flight from Connecticut to Cincinnati with the Xbox 360 packed in his luggage, when he arrived the console was mysteriously missing from his baggage.

Most people would understandably be a little miffed at this. Most people would probably expect the airline to provide enough compensation to replace the missing console with a new one. Jesse Maiman, it would appear, is not most people.

Maiman against US Airways seeking up to $1 million for non-economic stress, whatever that might be. OK, so allowing for the fact the Xbox 360 was modded with a specialised hard drive and other components that apparently cost more than a thousand dollars I can understand the $1700 being claimed to replace the console. But a million bucks on top?

Considering that the federal loss limits for any US airline when it comes to lost luggage, or belongings lost from luggage, is restricted to a liability of no more than $3,300 per bag I suspect he will be very lucky indeed to see anywhere near a million dollar pay day on this one.

Dani AI

Generated

This thread highlights two practical points: checked luggage is a risky place for expensive, customized electronics, and headline-grabbing damage claims seldom replace solid documentation and insurance. As observed, the carrier’s rules and the case paperwork will drive recoverable losses; ’s travel-insurance angle is the pragmatic fix, and ’s reality check about big awards is worth remembering.

When an item goes missing, immediate steps matter. At the airport, file a Property Irregularity Report (PIR) or equivalent and obtain a written reference; keep boarding passes and baggage tags. Photograph the empty bag, record serial numbers and model details, and assemble purchase receipts, photos of the console, and receipts for any aftermarket parts. Absent original receipts, bank/card statements, order emails, and dated photos often substantiate value.

Claim process: submit a written claim under the carrier’s contract of carriage, keep copies and proof of delivery, and follow the carrier’s stated time limits. Airlines typically reimburse proven monetary loss according to policy limits; claims for non-economic “stress” face a high evidentiary bar. Modifications usually void manufacturer warranties but do not automatically absolve a carrier of liability; however, modifications make establishing replacement value harder unless parts and costs are documented. Declared-value coverage or travel insurance is the reliable route for high-value gear.

Prevention: carry consoles in the cabin when permitted, photograph contents before travel, record serial numbers, attach external IDs, and insure or declare valuables when checking baggage. For disputes that reach litigation, legal counsel can clarify remedies and likely outcomes; small-claims courts commonly resolve replacement-cost disputes. And to and : the “millionaire” punchline is fun, but multimillion-dollar awards over a single missing checked console remain highly improbable.

samortan 0 Newbie Poster

I have got 2 , so does that mean I am millionaire, actually 2 millionaire

dra8ana 0 Newbie Poster

I have got 2 , so does that mean I am millionaire, actually 2 millionaire

Yeah, i am millionaire too!

JamieLynnSEO 20 Posting Pro in Training

He should have purchased travel insurance! This would have given him enough money to buy multiple x-box 360's! And probably a few games, too!

Regardless, id be pissed if my console were missing too.

JamieLynnSEO 20 Posting Pro in Training

((isn't modding your x box technically against Microsoft's policy? I know modding it generally voids a warranty... don't you think they'd find some legal loophole around this lawsuit? hm...))

happygeek 2,411 Most Valuable Poster Team Colleague Featured Poster

That story was from two years back, and I suspect if he was successful we would have heard about Microsoft having to cough up the cash :)

The MS lawyers probably told him in no uncertain terms to go away...

JamieLynnSEO 20 Posting Pro in Training

Too funny! ^_^

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.