Member Avatar for cmbadal

what is better option bookmarking or directory submission for best results in SEO

Edited by Dani because: Plug snipped
  • 6 Contributors
  • 5 Replies
  • 121 Views
  • 6 Months Discussion Span
  • Latest Post Latest Post by omgeles

Dani AI

Generated

asked whether bookmarking or directory submission is better. The replies from , , , and reflect the common short-term view: bookmarking can be faster for discovery and traffic than slow, low‑quality directory listings. That observation still matters, but the SEO landscape has changed since 2010 and a straight “bookmarking wins” answer is incomplete.

Directory links are now often low value or risky when they’re mass‑submitted, paid, or irrelevant; Google’s tools exist to remove or disavow harmful links if needed (). Social bookmarks and community posts usually use nofollow attributes, so they rarely move rankings directly but can drive clicks, indexation, and real user engagement. Quality, relevance, and editorial context matter far more than volume of listings.

Practical, up-to-date approach:

  • Prioritize creating content that earns editorial links (guest posts, expert roundups, unique data).
  • Use niche directories and local citation services only if they are reputable and relevant to the business (not generic link farms).
  • Treat social sites and bookmarking as distribution channels for content and traffic, not as a primary link-building strategy.
  • Audit backlinks regularly with Search Console or third‑party tools and disavow spammy directory links if they hurt the profile.
  • Avoid mass submission services or automated bookmarking tools; they waste time and risk penalties.

For a quick primer on modern link value and healthy SEO basics, see Moz’s guide (Beginner’s Guide to SEO). The one takeaway that ties back to earlier posts: speed of indexing and early traffic from bookmarks is useful, but long‑term SEO gains come from relevance and quality, not bulk submissions.

Recommended Answers

All 5 Replies

Member Avatar for johnsign11

Social Bookmarking is much more efficient, quick and qualitative compared to directory submissions...

Member Avatar for AirForceOne

Hi,

I think social bookmarking would be better not only for SEO purpose but also for traffic purpose if only you could use tags and reviews on those sites according to your targeted keywords tactically.

all the best,

Member Avatar for Bordeaux0113

I agree with the two above me :)

Member Avatar for seoiwc2010

in my view directory submission process are get too late to approve our site but Social book marks are not like that.... :) its my self experience.....

Member Avatar for omgeles

For SEO is better social bookmarking.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.