Apple Manager Arrested in Kickback Scheme

PCBrown 0 Tallied Votes 320 Views Share

Earlier this morning, Mercury News reported that a midlevel global supply manager at Apple, Paul Shin Devine, has been accused of accepting $1 million in kickbacks from iPod/iPhone accessory developers. He was arrested on charges of wire fraud, and money laundering, resulting in a federal indictment and a private civil suit from Apple related to the kickbacks.

Devine’s position within Apple meant that he was privy to sensitive trade information, which he would turn around and sell to Asian suppliers like Andrew Ang of Singapore. No specific companies were named, but they are described as suppliers of iPhone and iPod products and are located in various Asian countries, according to the indictment. With this knowledge, companies could have an upper hand when negotiating contracts and licenses with Apple, as well as the ability to gain a competitive advantage in the iPhone/iPod accessory market. He is accused of dealing with companies in China, Taiwan, Singapore and South Korea.

Devine relied on a series of U.S. and foreign bank accounts and as a shadow company posing as a front for the operation. In order to mask the intention of transfers, code words such as “sample” were used to identify transactions. One of the accounts was opened in his wife’s name, but she is not named as an accomplice in either case. Some payments for Devine went through CPK Engineering before ending up in his pocket. Devine was also known to travel to Asia, where he is suspected to have picked up kickbacks in person.

Apple’s PR lead, Steve Dowing had this to say: “Apple is committed to the highest ethical standards in the way we do business... We have zero tolerance for dishonest behavior inside or outside the company.” Devine will appear at the U.S. Northern District Court in San Jose on Monday, August 16, at 1:30 PM. The investigation was a joint effort between the FBI and IRS. Devine is currently being held by the U.S. Marshals Service.

[ Mercury News ]

Dani AI

Generated

Update to ’s original report with what happened after the August 2010 indictment and a short, practical checklist for teams that manage sensitive product information.

Paul S. Devine ultimately pleaded guilty on February 28, 2011 to wire fraud, conspiracy and money laundering and agreed to forfeit roughly $2.25 million. (archives.fbi.gov) He was later sentenced on December 1, 2014 to 12 months and one day in prison and ordered to pay $4,464,664 in restitution; the court set a February 19, 2015 start date for the custodial sentence. (justice.gov)

Public filings and press releases show Apple’s internal review (April 2010) triggered the FBI/IRS investigation that led to the indictment in August 2010; prosecutors later attributed about $2.4 million in kickback payments to the scheme and sought forfeiture of cash and other assets. (archives.fbi.gov)

Practical checklist for engineering, procurement and security teams (actions that can be implemented quickly):

  • Limit access: enforce least privilege for roadmaps/specs; require elevated approvals to export or share product forecasts.
  • Detection: deploy endpoint DLP and monitor for unusual bulk exports, external file transfers, or use of personal storage.
  • Financial controls: route supplier payments through centralized finance with anomaly detection for round-number or oddly labeled transfers.
  • Procurement governance: rotate sourcing responsibilities, require dual sign-off on vendor selection, and include audit rights and anti‑kickback clauses in supplier contracts.
  • Personnel controls: mandatory vacation, surprise audits, and clear conflict‑of‑interest disclosure requirements for vendor-facing staff.
  • Response plan: keep forensics playbooks current (forensic laptop imaging, preservation notices, quick legal/HR escalation paths).

This case is a reminder that supply‑chain roles are high‑risk from a confidentiality and fraud perspective; integrating simple technical controls with stronger procurement governance and monitoring materially reduces that risk. (justice.gov)

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.