Apple Sinks to Blocking Pre Sync

Techwriter10 0 Tallied Votes 711 Views Share

It was revealed yesterday that from syncing with iTunes. Apparently the latest upgrade, which I installed just this morning won't allow Pre users to sync with their phones.

Seriously, Apple? Are you really going to be this petty? Do you really feel this threatened by another company's phone that you would sink to blocking the ability to sync?

Who Are You Hurting Ultimately?

Some days the colossal stupidity of these large corporations astounds me. It really does. As a blogger, I peruse the web on a daily basis looking for ideas, for situations to which I can react, but when a company like Apple does something this monumentally self-destructive, it just makes it too easy.

Apple makes literally billions of dollars from the iTunes store. It's one of their cash cows. iTunes is just a piece of software for organizing your MP3 files. It doesn't care if you use a Palm Pre or an iPhone or Samsung Propel.

As I wrote yesterday about Microsoft in a similar vein, when you sell software and services, you tend to be hardware neutral, and this is even truer now that Apple has removed DRM from its music on the iTunes Store. What this does is tell a large swath of users that you don't care about them, that you are going to let pettiness overcome good business sense. Not what I would ever expect from a smart company like Apple

Why Are You Threatened Anyway

When it comes down to it, it show a shocking level of insecurity for a company that sells great products, products that speak for themselves. I took Microsoft to task the other day for conducting business by reacting to Apple's ads (in What's Next? A Google Store?) when I wrote:

Yes, Apple has made a lot of us laugh with their very amusing Get a Mac ads, but Microsoft can't run a company because they are pissed off that Apple made fun of them. It's just not a smart way to run a business.

I say the same thing to Apple. Grow up for goodness sakes. This is the real business world and this is no way to run your business.

Stock Looking Good, So Why Complain?

A recent say analysts are predicting a bright short-term future for Apple as the iPhone 3GS and the new 13 inch Mac Book Pro sales have been robust out of the gate. Jobs is back at the helm. iPhones are flying off the shelves and the $99 iPhone provides a buffer at the low end. The have resurfaced, which if true (and that's a big if) could provide another boost to Apple sales.

Given all this positive news, I'm guessing that Apple has little to worry about here, but like Microsoft, they sometimes seem to lose sight of sensible business practices. It makes me wonder if this is perhaps not an intentional slight at the Palm Pre , but an innocent engineering mistake being blown up out of proportion. If it's not though, it's time for Apple to smarten up and let the market decide. Indeed for the most part, it already has.

Dani AI

Generated

Brief history and technical cause: Apple released an iTunes update in mid‑July 2009 (iTunes 8.2.1) that, by design, disabled “devices falsely pretending to be iPods.” The Palm Pre’s built‑in media‑sync worked by presenting Apple-specific vendor/product IDs so iTunes would treat it like an iPod; that is why the July update immediately stopped Pre → iTunes syncing. Apple also posted an advisory warning that newer iTunes releases might not support non‑Apple digital media players. (macrumors.com)
MacRumors: iTunes 8.2.1 breaks Pre sync (and Apple advisory).(https://www.macrumors.com/2009/06/16/apple-issues-advisory-regarding-third-party-devices-syncing-with-itunes/)

What happened next and why it’s not just “pettiness”: Palm pushed webOS updates (webOS 1.1 and later patches) to re‑enable media sync and even complained to the USB Implementers Forum, arguing Apple had improperly used vendor‑ID checks. The USB‑IF responded by pointing out that Palm’s use of Apple’s vendor ID violated USB rules, and Apple kept shipping iTunes updates (iTunes 9 and subsequent revisions) that again broke Pre syncing. That pattern—device spoofing vs. vendor/device verification—turned this into a technical/standards spat rather than a single PR decision. (macrumors.com)
MacRumors: iTunes 9 breaks Pre sync (and USB‑IF ruling).(https://www.macrumors.com/2009/09/22/usb-compliance-organization-sides-with-apple-in-palm-pre-syncing-dispute/)

Practical takeaways for readers (then and now): if stable syncing matters, use vendor‑supported or third‑party sync tools that don’t rely on device spoofing (doubleTwist was a common workaround at the time), keep backups, and avoid assuming a proprietary client will remain compatible forever. For posterity: ’s frustration about consumer harm is valid; ’s point about buying into an integrated ecosystem trades convenience for resilience; ’s gadget passion is understood—but technical realities (USB IDs, support policies, standards rulings) drove this outcome more than a one‑off temper tantrum. (wired.com)
Wired on the sync cat‑and‑mouse and alternatives (and PCWorld on USB‑IF).(https://www.pcworld.com/article/519669/palm_pre_loses_in_usb_dispute_with_apple.html)

iphone rulz 0 Newbie Poster

Are you serious? Let Pre build their OWN damn iTunes store. Since when did Apple say the store was open source and free for any other company to ride on the back of? That's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Quit your bitchin' and buy and iPhone if you want the best experience.

Techwriter10 42 Practically a Posting Shark

I have news for you, I own an iPhone. My wife owns a Samsung Propel and she uses iTunes. It's just a tool to process video and MP3 files. You don't need to use an iPhone or an Ipod to use iTunes, and it's in Apple's best financial interest to make it available to everyone who wants to use it because there's a good chance if they are using iTunes, they're visiting the iTunes store.

Aviqc 0 Newbie Poster

Who cares about the music, it's the GADGET that counts!

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.