DaniWeb
Log In Sign Up
  • Read
  • Contribute
  • Meet
  1. Home
  2. Hardware and Software Forum
  3. macOS Forum
  4. News Stories
  5. News Story

Jailbreaking Your iPhone Now Legal, Won’t Get You 20 to Life

12 Years Ago Glass_Joe 1 Tallied Votes 952 Views Share

Thanks to a federal copyright law ruling on Monday by the Library of Congress, jailbreaking your iPhone doesn’t have to be kept to the underground forums like it's alcohol during a digital prohibition. The process is now completely legal under US law. Grab a glass of e-freedom! The resulting decision was part of a tri-yearly board review by the Library which discusses exemptions to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). The legalization of jailbreaking comprised two of the six provisions agreed upon today by the Library. See “ DMCA Changes: Copyright Rules Made More Flexible ”.

The filing was brought forth by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), who wanted handsets to be liberated from anticircumvention provisions in order to serve a greater purpose for their users who were living under a shadow of the “law's overbroad reach” with their hands tied with creative limitations.

Thanks to this victorious outcome, smartphone owners will be able to install lawfully obtained third-party apps or custom operating systems which unlock aspects of the phone otherwise shut off to an unassuming user. Also as a result of this decisions, owners will be able to install software which removes carrier limitations and circumvents restrictions, allowing universal access to network providers across all mobile fronts.

The Register of Copyrights, part of the Library of Congress, came to the following conclusion in regards to Apple’s defense:

[INDENT]“Apple is not concerned that the practice of jailbreaking will displace sales of its firmware or of iPhones. Indeed, since one cannot engage in that practice unless one has acquired an iPhone, it would be difficult to make that argument. Rather, the harm that Apple fears is harm to its reputation. Apple is concerned that jailbreaking will breach the integrity of the iPhone's ecosystem. The Register concludes that such alleged adverse effects are not in the nature of the harm that the fourth fair use factor is intended to address."

"Fewer than 50 bytes of code out of more than 8 million bytes, or approximately 1/160,000 of the copyrighted work as a whole. Where the alleged infringement consists of the making of an unauthorized derivative work, and the only modifications are so de minimis, the fact that iPhone users are using almost the entire iPhone firmware for the purpose for which it was provided to them by Apple undermines the significance"

"On balance, the Register concludes that when one jailbreaks a smartphone in order to make the operating system on that phone interoperable with an independently created application that has not been approved by the maker of the smartphone or the maker of its operating system, the modifications that are made purely for the purpose of such interoperability are fair uses."[/INDENT]

A heated debate between the U.S. Copyright Office and Apple began in February of 2009, when the EFF brought forth their initial filing. Apple claimed users who jailbroke their products and dissected its software to circumvent its intended purposes were in direct violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). They also cited a tremendous loss of company profits due to extended customer support man-hours, providing assistance to users suffering problems with jailbroken products. That debate ends today.

This is just another domino falling down in a row of losses looking to topple over the last in a line: Steve Jobs. Amongst reception woes and the iPhone Case Program being in full swing , Jobs is most likely somewhere crawled up in the fetal postion crying over the prospects of lost revenue from the iPhone App Store. After today, one thing is certain: he may take our money, but he will never take our freedom.

apple copyright iphone iphone-4 jailbreak jailbreaking
jailbreak.jpg 18.13 KB
About the Author
Member Avatar
Glass_Joe 68 Junior Poster in Training

I enjoy pizza, wheat ale, R.L. Stine novels, and collecting Pogs.
Favorite movies: Spice World, The Proposal, Step Up, Save the Last Dance, Over the Top, Bring It On, Thankskilling, The Room
Favorite music: Creed, Nickleback, Seether, 3 Doors Down, Ace of Base, Justin Bieber, the Evita Sountrack, NOW 1-295892

Member Avatar
Glass_Joe 68 Junior Poster in Training
12 Years Ago

Two words: good luck!

Member Avatar
ciidoctor 0 Newbie Poster
12 Years Ago

good news for iPhone lovers .thank you

Member Avatar
Progr4mmer 0 Junior Poster
12 Years Ago

good new for anyone with an ipod touch or iphone... but hopefully the free apps still remain illegal

Member Avatar
janellelk -1 Newbie Poster
12 Years Ago

My friend just alerted me to this. We're both T-mobile users. I was considering it but I've received such awful customer service from T-mobile lately I think I'm just going to wait out my contract and then completely switch over to AT&T or Verizon. Love the iPhone though.. :)

Member Avatar
Progr4mmer 0 Junior Poster
12 Years Ago

My friend just alerted me to this. We're both T-mobile users. I was considering it but I've received such awful customer service from T-mobile lately I think I'm just going to wait out my contract and then completely switch over to AT&T or Verizon. Love the iPhone though.. :)

my suggestion is verizon - much cheaper and service in more places

janellelk commented: really helpful +0
Member Avatar
janellelk -1 Newbie Poster
12 Years Ago

Progr4mmer, thanks so much for the advice.. I was leaning towards Verizon but after your recommendation and a few friends' suggestions for Verizon as well, I think my mind is made up. :)

Member Avatar
333Geek -2 Newbie Poster
12 Years Ago

Finally, Apple make some sense. Why can't we use free app (not cracked app) on our iphone/ipad? There are so many developers out there.

Member Avatar
CaptBah 0 Newbie Poster
9 Years Ago

Looking forword to being able to use more free apps.I hope more third party developers come to the resque.

Reply to this topic
Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.

Sign Up — It's Free!
Related Topics
  • Member Avatar iPhone 4 Carrier Unlock Released. Ultrasn0w Updated in Cydia 0
  • Member Avatar Apple Begins iPhone Case Program in App-auling Fashion 0
  • Member Avatar Sorry 2
  • Member Avatar iPhone 4’s FaceTime to Soon Support iPorn 3
  • Member Avatar Five Things That Didn't Happen at WWDC10 4
  • Member Avatar iMac OS X 10.4.8 help 2
  • Member Avatar iphone formatting 5
  • Member Avatar Apple Files Patent for Remote Disabling of Stolen and Jailbroken iPhones 3
  • Member Avatar OS X Apps keep opening in classic 9 4
  • Member Avatar upgrading failed to ios 5.1.1 3
  • Member Avatar Warning: iPhone exploit in the wild and stealing user data 1
  • Member Avatar Arrow Stuck 8
  • Member Avatar Apple confirms JailBreakMe fix coming soon 6
  • Member Avatar Why Apple was right about iMessage 'fix' for iPhone SMS spoofing 1
  • Member Avatar Instal or copy word from one imac to another 2
  • Member Avatar Is this the new iPod Touch 4? 6
  • Member Avatar iOS 4 10
  • Member Avatar Will Bad Press Flatten Future iPhone 4 Sales? 4
  • Member Avatar Apple iPhone 4 Reception Explanation Borders on Surreal 17
  • Member Avatar Are Apple users going green or just getting greedy? 1
Not what you need?

Reach out to all the awesome people in our macos community by starting your own topic. We equally welcome both specific questions as well as open-ended discussions.

Start New Topic
Topics Feed
Reply to this Topic
This topic is old! No one has contributed to this discussion in over 9 years. Are you sure you have something valuable to add to revive the existing conversation? Consider starting a new topic instead. Otherwise, please be thoughtful, detailed and courteous, and adhere to our posting rules.
  • Edit
  • Preview

Share Post

Insert Code Block

  • Forum Categories
  • Hardware/Software
  • Programming
  • Digital Media
  • Community Center
  • Latest Content
  • Newest Topics
  • Latest Topics
  • Latest Posts
  • Top Tags
  • Topics Feed
  • Social
  • Meet People
  • Forums
  • Top Members
  • Community Functions
  • DaniWeb Premium
  • Newsletter Archive
  • Markdown Syntax
  • Community Rules
  • Developer APIs
  • Connect API
  • Forum API Docs
  • Tools
  • SEO Backlink Checker
  • Legal
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • FAQ
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
© 2023 DaniWeb® LLC