Member Avatar for OpenPress.Com

Before you higher any so called "SEO experts" ya better read this:

  • 8 Contributors
  • 9 Replies
  • 474 Views
  • 14 Years Discussion Span
  • Latest Post Latest Post by lewisclark019

Dani AI

Generated

This thread documents a familiar pattern: overpromising SEOs, secretive tactics, and small businesses left with bills or penalties. Early posts from and warned about shady providers, described being deprioritized by a large agency, and later posters such as , and echoed that small businesses are prime targets. Two durable points from Google: no legitimate SEO can guarantee #1 rankings, and site owners remain responsible for what contractors do on their sites. (developers.google.com)

A practical vetting checklist (keeps risk low and clarifies expectations):

  • Request contactable case studies (client name + URL) and speak directly with at least one former client.
  • Require a written scope: measurable KPIs, deliverables, reporting cadence, and an explicit exit/transfer plan for domains/accounts.
  • Demand method transparency: no “secret” link networks, no promises of guaranteed rankings, and simple explanations of tactics.
  • Limit access: use role-based accounts (not full admin/FTP ownership) and require change logs for site edits.
  • Start with a paid audit or short trial project before signing long retainers.

These are common red flags and vetting steps recommended across the industry. (searchengineland.com)

Link-building deserves special caution. Unsupervised link buying, private-blog-network tactics, or automated mass outreach can trigger algorithmic nullification or manual action; Google’s recent guidance and link-spam updates make this enforcement explicit. When harmful or suspicious links appear, attempt removal first and—only after careful audit—use Search Console’s disavow workflow as a remediation step. (developers.google.com)

If deception or aggressive cold-calls occur, keep all contracts, invoices and correspondence and report fraud to the authorities (ReportFraud.ftc.gov). The FTC has pursued directory and telemarketing schemes that target small businesses; documenting incidents and reporting them helps enforcement and protects other businesses. When feasible, an independent technical or link audit before a large contract can prevent costly remediation later. (ftc.gov)

Recommended Answers

All 9 Replies

Member Avatar for motech

Before you higher any so called "SEO experts" ya better read this:

Yes.. Hiring an seo expert is probably a bad idea. Hiring a firm would be a better
idea if your company depends on seo traffic.

The article definitely points out some of the shadier practices in place by the
smaller seo companies that cannot compete in todays market.

Always listen to good advice. Always question someone's name bashing without proof.

Member Avatar for Mr.'BackUp'

I have had bad experience with big SEO companies in so far as if your not spending as much as their bigger clients, then invariably your not going to be a priority. I was given the run around for about 6 months, only to be presented with a bill which didint justify the work done,and didn't give my ranking anymore weighting. I felt as if it was a scam - in so far as I was fed a yarn at the sales pitch and led up the garden path.

So I would say - go for one man bands who can prove what they have done with existing clients

<< Moderator Removed: Please setup a signature via your user profile >>

Member Avatar for seobook

So I would say - go for one man bands who can prove what they have done with existing clients

I am a big fan of smaller SEOs too.

Member Avatar for Dani

I'm wondering if it might even be worth it to hire individuals with little to no SEO experience to do link building campaigns for you. Ya know, the tedious part of SEO ;)

Member Avatar for rrram2

Hire an SEO expert...ONLY if you know where they live! :Þ

commented: thread's been dead since 10 years ago, why did you bother -3
Member Avatar for rrram2

Well almostbob, after being here for 7 years and mostly reading stuff and not saying anything, I needed one more post since apparantly I needed 5 posts to get "full functionality". Anymore stupid questions? Or do you have any real questions? or just potshots? or was that a rhetorical question? Or are you just a smart ass?

Member Avatar for asbarkhan

Nowadays, Many fake experts are coming in the market and it is hard but not imposible to hire the real expert.

commented: As above, this is a 10 year old thread or older. Start new please. -3
Member Avatar for lewisclark019

SEO scammers typically target small businesses that have sparse resources as they offer little-to-no threat when they discover that they have been taken advantage of differnt ways.

commented: As above, this is a 10 year old thread or older. Start new please. -3
Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.