Measuring Facebook Success: Altimeter Knows How

Updated CatRambo 0 Tallied Votes 322 Views Share

Altimeter Group's recently released report establishes eight criteria for measuring success with Facebook page marketing and used the criteria to measure thirty brands, finding that the majority aren't making the most of their Facebook pages. Pamper's, Macy's, Kohl's and AXE, on the other hand, were brands successfully using Facebook marketing to increase word of mouth and brand recognition. More and more companies are using Facebook to reach customers, with more than 45% of senior marketers identifying social networks as their priority for this year.

Facebook, the report says, is a platform that marketers cannot ignore. Recently Facebook passed the 500 million user mark, with users spending more time on Facebook each day than on Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Wikipedia, Yahoo, and YouTube combined.

So what are the eight criteria? Setting community expectations, providing cohesive branding, staying up to date, maintaining live authenticity, participating in dialog, enabling peer-to-peer interaction, fostering advocacy, and soliciting a call to action.Setting community expectations: Companies need to tell consumers both what they can expect from the brand's Facebook page, such as news, tips, coupons, or user support, as well as what the company wants from fans. Posting community guidelines and moderation guidelines helps users understand why inappropriate content might be removed.

Providing cohesive branding: Companies should make the most of Facebook customization in order to make their band distinctive. They may want to create custom applications or tabs that help provide a distinctive brand experience.

Staying up to date: Pages need to stay fresh, both to entice new users and to give followers a reason to stay engaged with the brand's page.

Maintaining live authenticity: Brands should make the most of the people-to-people connections that Facebook offers by creating a conversation with their followers, using administrator names and photos to reinforce the user's sense of engaging with another human being.

Participating in dialogue: Brands should respond to fans in discussions as well as initiating its own discussions. Fan comments should be acknowledged to make consumers feel appreciated and encourage them to share their interactions with the brand with other friends.

Enabling peer-to-peer interaction: Fans should be able to respond to each other, and offer each other support. This requires a community policy and moderation to facilitate that interaction.

Fostering advocacy: Encourage fans to share or like posts by having them do something on the page, such as voting in a poll, that is worth sharing with their friends. Contests, polls. and submissions all invite users to participate and share.

Soliciting a call to action: Give fans something to do other than simply read posts by asking them to "Like" or share items or sign-up for the brand's newsletter.

In looking at brands, Altimeter found that retail industries and consumer goods/products tended to use Facebook more effectively than luxury hotels or regulated industries. Most brands fell short in setting expectations although brands currently facing controversy, such as BP, tended to score high in this area.

Dani AI

Generated

Altimeter’s eight criteria (as summarized by ) remain a useful strategic checklist — they describe what a good Facebook presence looks and feels like. The context around those criteria has changed, though: platform distribution, privacy, and measurement methods have all moved on, so the same checklist needs modern instrumentation and clearer, business-focused KPIs.

Organic distribution is much harder than it was in 2010; algorithms now reward meaningful engagement and short-form, native formats (Reels, Stories) while brands increasingly use paid support to scale reach and outcomes. Recent industry guidance emphasizes mixing short-form video and interactive formats with community-building tactics rather than relying on follower counts alone. (blog.hootsuite.com)

Privacy and tracking changes forced a measurement shift. Apple’s App Tracking Transparency and browser tracking limits reduced client-side identifiers; platforms now recommend server-to-server event collection (Conversions API) to complement the browser pixel and improve match quality and attribution. Instrumentation should therefore include both pixel and server-side event flows, plus verified domain/EMQ checks. (developer.apple.com)

A practical, modern measurement checklist that maps back to Altimeter’s ideas:

  • pick one business metric (revenue, CPA, LTV) as the north star and map funnel KPIs to it;
  • implement Pixel + Conversions API and validate Event Match Quality;
  • apply consistent UTM/GA4 tagging and tie on-site conversions to CRM revenue where possible;
  • run controlled experiments (conversion-lift, brand-lift or geo/holdout tests) to measure incrementality rather than rely on last-click or vanity metrics; and
  • use lift results to decide how much paid amplification is needed to scale community outcomes into sales. Conversion-lift and holdout studies are the accepted way to isolate incremental impact. ()

The reminder from — that Facebook alone does not guarantee revenue — is on point. The best practice is to treat Facebook as a channel in a broader measurement plan, instrument it for conversion and incrementality, and optimize against clear economic outcomes rather than raw Likes or fan counts.

Member Avatar for Member #949455
Member #949455

In looking at brands, Altimeter found that retail industries and consumer goods/products tended to use Facebook more effectively than luxury hotels or regulated industries. Most brands fell short in setting expectations although brands currently facing controversy, such as BP, tended to score high in this area.

This is an interesting article regarding how Facebook misleading companies thinking they (companies) can make more money with Facebook. It can go both ways since you mention a few companies.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.